Last night, the historic Blue Moon Hotel transformed into a dazzling hub of light, music, and celebration as it hosted the unforgettable Festa di Hanukkah. Beginning at 6:30 PM, the evening delivered a spectacular fusion of cherished traditions, festive spirit, and contemporary charm, creating an experience that truly captured the essence of the holiday.
🍝 Italian Delights that Dazzled
The kosher (Cholov Yisroel) Italian dishes were a true feast for the senses, expertly blending authentic Italian flavors with strict kosher standards. Guests raved about the innovative fusion that transformed traditional recipes into something extraordinary. Randy Settenbrino, the organizer and owner of the Historic Blue Moon Hotel, shared with the New York Jewish Travel Guide (NYJTG) why the venue was the ideal setting for Festa di Hanukkah: a unique blend of Hanukkah traditions with an Italian flair. “We honor the legacy of my Nona Carolina by offering authentic recipes from her Trattoria Vesuvio, reimagined into a kosher dining experience,” he explained. “Our kosher Italian menu, inspired by our Pasticceria and Trattoria, is a heartfelt tribute to the essence of Italian cooking and baking, crafted in the artisanal style of the 1920s.”
The standout dishes for Hanukkah were nothing short of spectacular. The zucchini, patate e scalogni frittelle—a savory combination of potatoes, and scallions—was an irresistible treat. The zucchini latkes, served with fragrant pesto and a rich, were an absolute highlight. Paired with succulent salmon and a medley of mixed Italian vegetables, these dishes were a true feast for the senses. These mouthwatering creations left me eagerly anticipating my next visit to savor these exceptional dishes again at this extraordinary kosher restaurant.
🍇 Cheers to Hanukkah!
The open bar was a major hit, featuring an impressive selection of drinks. The thought behind offering an open bar and carefully selecting the drinks for the event was intentional, as Randy noted, “Wine gladdens the heart.” The event offered imported Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Grigio, Chianti, and sangria—perfectly complementing the menu. Beer and other beverages were also available, ensuring there was something for everyone. Guests mingled, toasted, and enjoyed the warm camaraderie of the evening.
The Blue Moon Hotel was the perfect venue for this festive occasion. Its historic charm and inviting elegance created a warm, welcoming atmosphere that made the evening feel both intimate and majestic. The flickering candlelight of the menorah bathed the space in a magical glow, perfectly enhancing the joyful spirit of the celebration.
✨ What truly made Festa di Hanukkah special was the sense of community it fostered. Guests from all walks of life came together to celebrate the Festival of Lights, share stories, and create lasting memories. The blend of tradition and modern celebration was seamless, reminding everyone of the timeless miracles that Hanukkah represents.
Barbara, a guest visiting from Austria with her husband, shared her enthusiasm with NYJTG about their stay at a charming family-run hotel and her unforgettable Hanukkah experience. “I’ve never participated in such a beautiful Hanukkah celebration—it was such a delightful surprise. We are thrilled to be staying here. Everything is wonderful, and the hotel’s rich history adds so much character. I especially appreciate that it’s family-run, as it reminds me of my own guest house back in Austria,” she said. Barbara also shared her upcoming travel plans to explore other states, noting her preference for personal, family-owned accommodations that offer a quiet and private retreat. The traditional food, warm atmosphere, and unique history of the hotel made both the Hanukkah celebration and her stay truly exceptional.
Randy concluded that he hopes this event will grow or evolve in future years and that The Historic Blue Moon will become a hub for Jewish arts and cultural life. “It is the ideal setting to serve functions and provide community for Jews in the arts to congregate. The message I want my guests to take away from Festa di Hanukkah is that spirituality and creativity have the power to uplift our people and foster connection among Jews. There are many ways The Historic Blue Moon can serve the greater Jewish communities, enhancing our efforts to gain visibility as a beacon of what once was and what will be our shared destiny.”
As the night drew to a close, the warm glow of the menorah lights and the echoes of music, laughter, and heartfelt camaraderie filled the air. Guests departed with full hearts, cherished memories, and a renewed connection to the timeless traditions of Hanukkah. From the tantalizing aroma of freshly fried latkes to the joy of spinning dreidels and the unity of voices raised in song, every moment celebrated the festival’s spirit of light and resilience.
If you missed this year’s Festa di Hanukkah, don’t worry—the magic will return next year, even bigger and brighter. Be sure to mark your calendar, as it’s not just a celebration; it’s an unforgettable experience that brings the community together in a joyous embrace of heritage and togetherness. Be sure to join the celebration and create unforgettable memories at this joyous Hanukkah tradition!
Meyer Harroch, New York Jewish Travel Guide
Randy/Yisroel Settenbrino is the artist and developer behind the Historic Blue Moon Hotel, The Sweet Dreams Café, and the Last Jewish Tenement Tours. National Geographic selected his project as one of the top 150 in the Western Hemisphere.
